home arrow OPINIONS arrow Judges have responsibility to make fearless decisions

AP Political Videos

Login Form

Lost Password?
No account yet? Register
Judges have responsibility to make fearless decisions PDF Print E-mail
Written by JAMES E. C. PERRY   
Monday, 15 October 2012

james_e.c._perry.jpgThis November, Floridians will vote on whether to retain three Florida Supreme Court Justices and 15 District Court of Appeal judges.

They’re not on the ballot because they did something wrong; rather, it’s just business as usual under Florida’s merit retention system, which requires that all Florida Supreme Court Justices and appellate court judges appear on the ballot in six-year cycles based upon when they were appointed by the governor. 

As a current member of the Supreme Court, I can neither support nor oppose fellow justices or any of the appellate court judges on the ballot.

However, I can speak out about the purpose of merit retention and ask that when you go to the voting booth you consider the importance of a separate judicial branch in our system of government which is built on a foundation of “checks and balances” and “separation of powers.”  It is much like a stool delicately balanced on three legs.

A lot of power

One leg is the legislative branch, which makes the laws.  Our Legislature pass-es laws covering a broad range of topics affecting just about every aspect of our lives and taking up almost 11,000 pages of small type.  That’s a lot of power.

Another leg of the stool helps balance that power. Specifically, the executive branch, which implements the laws, is headed by the governor, who has the authority to veto laws and keep them from going into effect.  To enforce and implement the laws that do go into effect, the governor presides over more than two dozen agencies. Again, that’s a lot of power. 

The third leg of the stool helps balance the legislative and executive branch power combined.  Specifically, the judicial branch is charged with interpreting laws and constitutional
provisions.  That means that the judicial branch can in the end strike down a law that was passed and implemented by the legislative and executive branches, even if the law is very popular.  That can make the judicial branch very unpopular.  After all, the people liked the law and it was enacted and enforced by officials that they elected, so what’s the problem?

Without fear

The problem is that even popular laws can offend the very foundation of our society — the Constitution.  A great example is Brown v. Board of Education, a 1954 case in which black children had been denied admission to schools attended by white children under laws requiring or permitting segregation according to race.

The United States Supreme Court concluded that “[s]eparate educational facilities are inherently unequal.  Therefore, we hold that [the children] . . . are, by reason of the segregation complained of, deprived of the equal protection of the laws guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment” of the Constitution. 

Brown was so unpopular it led to riots.  But mob rule does not govern our country; the rule of law does.  A core constitutional principle is the protection of the powerless from “the tyranny of the masses.”

The justices in Brown could address that tyranny without fear of being kicked off the court, as United States Supreme Court justices are appointed for life.  Their independence was assured because they were insulated against political or popular pressure or retaliation.

They could do their jobs properly precisely because they were without fear of losing them.       

Unpopular decisions

But Florida Supreme Court justices and appellate court judges face a merit retention vote every six years.  Some suggest that they should be voted out of office for making certain difficult decisions.

While politicians in the other two branches are elected to follow the “will of the people,” the judicial branch must follow the Constitution.  So, when you vote, I hope you’ll consider that sometimes

Florida Supreme Court justices and appellate court judges have the absolute responsibility to make difficult decisions in order to uphold core constitutional principles that in the end serve and protect us all.

Their ability to be fair and impartial and at times make unpopular decisions ensures that all three legs of the stool — the legislative, executive, and judicial branches — remain in
balance.  Cut one leg of the stool short and it all crashes to the ground. 

So, make no mistake.  It’s not just about the Florida Supreme Court justices and appellate court judges on the ballot.  It’s much bigger than that.  The integrity of the entire judicial branch —and, therefore, the overall balance of our state’s government — is in play. 

Look at it this way: Will Florida Supreme Court justices and appellate court judges in the future hesitate to make difficult decisions that they believe are required of them if their colleagues have been voted out of office for doing just that? 
You be the judge.

James E. C. Perry was appointed to the Florida Supreme Court by Gov. Charlie Crist and took office there on March 11, 2009. Before his appointment, he served as a circuit judge of Florida's Eighteenth Judicial Circuit upon his appointment by Gov. Jeb Bush in March 2000.
Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comments.

Last Updated ( Monday, 15 October 2012 )
< Prev   Next >
Microsoft reveals Siri-like Windows Phone featureMicrosoft reveals Siri-like Windows Phone feature
NEW YORK — Microsoft unveiled a new virtual assistant for Windows Phone devices last Wednesday as it seeks to gain tra...
Google Glass, good for cooking, needs InternetGoogle Glass, good for cooking, needs Internet
NEW YORK — Google Glass is like a fickle friend. Surprises await, such as the time it took a photo of my ceiling while...
FTC says operators of jerk.com deceived consumersFTC says operators of jerk.com deceived consumers
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Federal Trade Commission says the operators of a website called Jerk.com are the ones behaving badl...
‘Rio 2’ dazzling but overloaded ‘Rio 2’ dazzling but overloaded
A vivid and delightful animated spectacle, Rio 2 is chock-full of colorful 3-D wonder and jubilant musical numbers set ...

News Article Comments

NRA-backed ‘warning-shot’ law on Scott’s desk
The proposed law changes deal with threatening to use deadly force, warning shots are the use of deadly force. The changes will actually water down the SYG law a bit like suggested by Taryvon Martin ...
Miami Gardens chief from North Miami
Congratulations and welcome to the City of Miami Gardens!
Doctors say prepare kids for summer camp
As a camp Director of Swift Nature Camp , I understand and see all the benefits of camp each and every summer. However, it is important to pick the right camp, especially in Fla. At this time they a...
Minority Groups defend Florida's Gay marriage ban
The kettle once called the pan black, the ignorance and arrogance of this group is mind blowing
National Civil Rights Museum reopens at site of King shooting
So happy to see this important museum reopen. Let's hope the politics stay out of the way of success.
Minority Groups defend Florida's Gay marriage ban
Can these groups not see the foolishness of their stance? Ignorance is not always bliss when you're so concerned with what other humans lives. Don't like gay marriage? Don't get gay married. DuH!
Workers to mark MLK assassination anniversary with rally
We cannot forget this important anniversary. Dr. King was murdered partly because of this strike.
Washington Park in need of improvement: OIC offering assistance
thanks for sharing this buon gi bay gio | may tinh de ban | tri ho |
Broward mayor’s success a tribute to late father
What a Great story! I stopped reading the article to say, "This is news that is Current, Local, about Living Legends and their descendants contributing to the African Diaspora. Keep Telling The Stor...
Minority Groups defend Florida's Gay marriage ban
Oh the shear hypocrisy of Blacks and Hispanics not supporting equal rights for all. We should be ashamed for using the same techniques used on us to deny rights to others which are guaranteed by the c...
Mall project a big break for 2 women
Congratulations are in Order! You BOTH Work Hard and Smart, and know how to have Fun while doing it. Your Intelligence and Hearts of Gold Will Pay off....GOD'S ABUNDANT BLESSINGS
Mall project a big break for 2 women
Your enthusiasm, drive and insight is truly inspiring. I wish you bot! many years of great achievements! Keep up the great work!
Mall project a big break for 2 women
What an awesome job ladies! This is the type is professionalism and success that motivates me and my business venture. I'm truly proud of you both. Keep up the fantastic work!
Broward mayor’s success a tribute to late father
Good story, anyone should be applauded for turning around their situation. But sometimes people don't act like they know where they came from and have not done anything for their community except to a...
Mall project a big break for 2 women
Congrats Ladies! Job well done!
Mall project a big break for 2 women
Congratulations Ann Marie!!! I'm so proud of you!!! Way to go! Keep your passion, and God will do the rest! Love you!
Mall project a big break for 2 women
I am so proud of both of you ladies! What a great example and a great job! I am most proud of Ann for defying the stereotypes and proving awesome things do come from the muck! Much continued success!
Miami Gardens: Don’t cut us out
If I were Ross I would move the team and dump the stadium. It is obvious Miami Gardens no longer appreciates what the Dolphins bring to the area but rather collect that guaranteed check. Great example...
Clinton says she's still considering future plans
Mushtaq Dean In this interview session, a woman showed her desire that Hillary should try to win the highest position and represent female population. She was single in her physical appearance but was...
The young are trapped by obsession with wealth
This is a well-conceived and well-written article and does, indeed, express my observations as well as my sentiments. In July, I will be on a panel at The Futurist Conference in Orlando discussing the...

The most influential African American weekly newspaper in South Florida

Beatty Media LLC