The sexual encounter between Winston and Carroll’s client happened on Dec. 7, 2012. Winston’s attorney has said more than once that the sex was consensual. No charges were filed against Winston by Leon County prosecutors who investigated the case nearly a year after the woman said the attack happened.
But Carroll said her client, who was an FSU student at the time, was sexually assaulted. The woman was 19 and reported what happened to Tallahassee Police.
At a mid-December news conference, Carroll criticized the way the police investigation was handled, saying that detectives failed to interview key witnesses, used unreliable and incomplete forensic tests and never tested the alleged victim’s blood for the presence of date-rape drugs. Carroll said that her client was “treated like a suspect.”
Tallahassee police have defended their handling of the case and Carroll said she received a letter from the department that said an internal affairs investigation found that the case was handled with proper procedures.
Carroll has also criticized police for not submitting her client’s sexual assault kit to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement lab until Jan. 17, 2013, 39 days after it was taken. The attorney questioned whether evidence was properly preserved during those 39 days.
Carroll says she asked Florida’s attorney general, the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and the governor for an independent examination into the rape investigation, claiming it was riddled with problems.
Scott “didn’t even give us the courtesy of a response,” Carroll said Thursday.
On December 13, Scott, through a spokeswoman, said he declined to look into the matter.
Carroll sent Scott a letter on Dec. 19, along with one from the woman and her mother.
The documents were released Thursday by Scott’s office following a public records request. Attempts by email and phone to reach the governor’s office for comment didn’t get an immediate response.
In a one-page letter, the woman who has accused Winston told Scott that her attorney received calls from two other FSU students who said they were raped, but were “discouraged” from going through with a prosecution. Carroll said the family members of those two women contacted her following her December news conference.
The Associated Press does not normally identify people who say they may have been victims of sexual assault.
The accuser’s mother said in her letter that she knows the governor has daughters and asked him to “put yourself in my shoes for a moment.”
Her daughter did not “fabricate” a rape, the woman wrote, and did not know Winston prior to Dec. 7, 2012.
“I want to tell you about my daughter with the hopes that you will see her as a real person and not just some name on a police report,” the mother wrote, adding that her daughter was heavily involved in school activities and was a leader on sports teams and student government.
“I am hoping that this letter makes an impact on your decision and you direct FDLE to open an investigation into the Tallahassee Police Department’s handling of this matter. I will not give up on my daughter and will do everything in my power to see that everyone finds out the truth.”
The 20-year-old Winston became the second freshman to win the Heisman trophy given to college football’s most outstanding player.
He joined Charlie Ward and Chris Weinke as the school’s three Heisman winners.
Winston led Florida State to its first undefeated season and national championship since 1999 after setting national freshman records for yards passing and touchdown passes. The Seminoles defeated Auburn 34-31 to capture the third national title in school history.